I am not entirely familiar with all of them, of course -- not all of the seventh-years are in my NEWT classes, and those who are not were among those who surprised me. Likewise, Smith -- though capable enough, I suppose -- has never struck me as anything but a follower.
The other halfblood is Dean Thomas. He keeps his own counsel; I've never been able to figure out what's going on under that mop of hair. I do know he has difficulty working with his peers. When Savitha and I were supervising the CCF activities this summer, he was the one the children most often chose to pass to the other team or to send off alone. He did well enough, I suppose, and for all that Our Lord values cooperation among His initiates, He also values cunning -- and cunning is undoubtedly something one can learn in a mudblood camp. We shall see.
I was also surprised at the inclusion of Nott's boy. I have found him a most challenging student: his abilities with the Arts are prodigious, but his judgement is exceptionally poor. I can only hope age will bring maturity with it, and should he be chosen, that he is more willing to listen to the counsel of his elders in Our Lord's service than he is to listen to his teacher in a classroom setting.
I am more on your side of the wager than Cadmus's, I will confess. Again, both boys are capable enough with the Arts, but intellect is not the strong suit of either. Still, I suppose Our Lord has need of muscle as well as wit.
no subject
The other halfblood is Dean Thomas. He keeps his own counsel; I've never been able to figure out what's going on under that mop of hair. I do know he has difficulty working with his peers. When Savitha and I were supervising the CCF activities this summer, he was the one the children most often chose to pass to the other team or to send off alone. He did well enough, I suppose, and for all that Our Lord values cooperation among His initiates, He also values cunning -- and cunning is undoubtedly something one can learn in a mudblood camp. We shall see.
I was also surprised at the inclusion of Nott's boy. I have found him a most challenging student: his abilities with the Arts are prodigious, but his judgement is exceptionally poor. I can only hope age will bring maturity with it, and should he be chosen, that he is more willing to listen to the counsel of his elders in Our Lord's service than he is to listen to his teacher in a classroom setting.
I am more on your side of the wager than Cadmus's, I will confess. Again, both boys are capable enough with the Arts, but intellect is not the strong suit of either. Still, I suppose Our Lord has need of muscle as well as wit.